How DMOs Should Measure SEO Performance Today

Tracking the right SEO KPIs is crucial for Destination Marketing Organizations (DMOs) and Convention & Visitors Bureaus (CVBs) to measure success, optimize strategies, and deliver meaningful results. As search algorithms, traveler expectations, and the search landscape evolve, relying on traditional SEO metrics no longer provides an accurate view of performance and can lead to misguided strategies.

In this guide, we’ll outline our strategic approach to SEO measurement tailored specifically for DMOs and CVBs, including:

• Why the evolving SEO landscape demands smarter, more relevant KPIs
• Which traditional SEO metrics to leave behind
• Essential new SEO metrics to track for destination marketing
• Communicating modern SEO KPI value to stakeholders
• Foundational steps to future-proof your SEO measurement starting today

Why Traditional SEO Metrics Are Insufficient for DMOs and CVBs

Several factors make traditional SEO metrics less relevant today:

Rise of Zero-Click and AI-Powered Searches:

Travelers often find immediate answers directly on Google's SERP through AI Overviews, FAQs, featured snippets, and other advanced features. A recent study of 300,000 keywords found that AI Overviews reduce clicks by 34.5%, which helps explain why nearly 60% of searches now end without a click, making traditional SEO metrics like website traffic and clicks a lot less meaningful.

Impact: Traditional metrics such as clicks, CTR, and total traffic alone no longer fully represent destination marketing success.

Complex Traveler Journeys & Diverse Search Platforms:

Today's travelers engage through multiple platforms, including TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and niche travel platforms, not just traditional search engines.

Impact: DMOs must measure SEO success across all digital touchpoints, emphasizing engagement beyond Google.

Increasingly Sophisticated Algorithms:

Search engines now heavily factor content relevance, user intent, and site experience, such as load times, mobile usability, and Core Web Vitals.

Impact: Strong SEO performance requires measurement frameworks reflecting content quality, user engagement, and technical site health.

SEO Metrics DMOs & CVBs Should Deprioritize:

• Keyword Rankings: High rankings don't always drive meaningful engagement or tourism conversions.
• Exact-Match Keywords: Search intent and content relevance are prioritized over specific keyword usage.
• Organic Traffic Alone: Traffic volumes without context or engagement insights can misrepresent true success.
• Organic Click-Through Rates (CTR): Rising zero-click searches reduce CTR reliability.
• Total Keyword Footprint: Volume of keywords ranked doesn’t always indicate valuable traveler engagement.

While these metrics remain informative, DMOs should shift primary focus to more strategic indicators of organic search success.

Smarter SEO KPIs DMOs & CVBs Should Track:

For DMOs, true success means measuring how well your content engages travelers, drives discovery, and contributes to real-world tourism outcomes. Here are the key SEO KPIs that matter most in this AI-first search era.

1. Engagement-Based Metrics:

Understand content effectiveness and traveler interactions.

• Engaged sessions (GA4)
• Engagement rate
• Average engagement time
• Bounce rate
• Scroll depth
• Social shares and interactions

2. SERP Visibility Metrics:

Capture traveler awareness and discoverability.

• Organic impressions (brand/category-specific)
• New website visitors
• Presence in SERP features (e.g., AI overviews, local packs, video snippets)
• Referral traffic from AI search platforms (e.g., ChatGPT, Perplexity)

3. Destination Business Impact Metrics:

Demonstrate SEO’s role in attracting visitors and driving economic impact.

• Conversions (event attendance, bookings, Visitor Guide or newsletter sign-ups)
• Organic search conversion rates
• Revenue attributed to organic search (where trackable)
• Event and activity-specific interactions (brochure downloads, itinerary planners)
• Lifetime value of visitors

4. Brand Loyalty & Visibility:

Strengthen awareness and traveler preference.

• Branded keyword impressions
• Branded keyword engagement (clicks)

5. Technical Health & Site Experience Metrics:

Optimize the traveler’s digital experience.

• Core Web Vitals
• Page load speed
• Mobile responsiveness

6. Competitive Visibility Metrics:

Benchmark against competing destinations.

• Organic share of voice in travel searches
• Comparative visibility metrics vs. competitors (Ahrefs)

Communicating Modern SEO KPIs to Stakeholders:

To drive understanding and alignment, DMOs must translate modern SEO metrics into meaningful business impact that resonates with stakeholders, connecting performance data to tourism outcomes and broader organizational goals.

Here are some quick tips to help make this refined approach to SEO measurement more tangible and compelling to your internal and external stakeholders:

• Elevate your storytelling to highlight the deeper impact of your efforts—moving beyond surface metrics to emphasize the connection between SEO metrics and economic/tourism outcomes.
• Educate stakeholders on the rationale behind new metrics.
• Showcase real-world examples and success stories to reinforce credibility.
• Proactively adjust your reporting frameworks and dashboards.

Getting Started with Future-Forward SEO Measurement

Adopting a more modern, impact-focused SEO measurement strategy doesn’t require a complete overhaul overnight – it starts with intentional, strategic shifts.

Here’s how DMOs can begin:

1. Audit your current SEO reporting: Identify which metrics are still rooted in outdated performance indicators (e.g., rankings or raw traffic) and where engagement, SERP visibility, or business impact data could tell a more complete story.
2. Align your KPIs with destination goals: Choose metrics that reflect the full traveler journey – from inspiration to conversion – and demonstrate how SEO supports broader tourism, visitation, and economic development objectives.
3. Collaborate across teams: Conduct brainstorming sessions across content, strategy, media, UX, and analytics teams to ensure your SEO measurement reflects cross-channel activity, AI search behavior, and traveler experience signals.
4. Experiment and iterate: Test new tracking methods—like scroll depth or AI referral traffic—and explore additional data sources such as Ahrefs or SEMrush. Continuously refine your dashboards and reporting decks to highlight the insights that matter most to stakeholders.
5. Educate and advocate: Proactively communicate the value of these modern SEO KPIs  to leadership and partners build buy-in and long-term investment in organic search as a key driver of destination growth.

By starting with small, focused changes and building cross-functional alignment, DMOs can unlock deeper insights and set the foundation for sustainable SEO success in today’s rapidly evolving search landscape.

Interested in learning more about AI? Check out DI's new Technology and Innovation Series.